| |
"The Campaign for Safer and Smarter
Police Pursuits." 2004. [http://www.pursuitwatch.org].
Abstract: The goal of the organization is to educate the public, police
and the press about police pursuits. Provides a resource for law enforcement
for the development and implementation of safe and responsible pursuit
policy.
Alpert, Geoffrey P. Police in Pursuit: Policy and Practice. Washington,
DC: National Institute of Justice, 1996. Call Number: HV8080.P9 P65 1996
AV Notes: VHS, (50 minutes) color.
Abstract: Examines a variety of issues related to the policy and practice
of police vehicular pursuits, including the outcomes of police pursuits,
the offenses that occasion pursuits, reasons why suspects run from police,
police attitudes toward pursuits, and department policy toward pursuits.
Alpert, Geoffrey P. and Lorie A. Firdell. Police Vehicles and Firearms:
Instruments of Deadly Force. Prospect Heights, IL: Waveland, 1992. Call
Number: HV 8080.P9 A47 1992
Abstract: Pursuit driving must be looked at with the understanding that
police serve the state and the state's interest, not the individual citizen.
Law enforcement agencies must have rules, regulations, training and supervision
to control the discretion of their officers. Written and enforced policies
are necessary for the proper management of all law enforcement functions.
Alpert, Geoffrey P. and Roger C. Dunham. Police Pursuit Driving: Controlling
Responses to Emergency Situations. New York: Greenwood Press, 1990. Call
Number: HV8080.P9 A46 1990
Abstract: The purpose of this monograph is to analyze another form of
potential deadly force, the police pursuit. When an officer becomes engaged
in a chase, the vehicles involved become potential dangerous weapons.
The analogy between shootings and pursuits used here is informative, but
the comparisons between vehicles and guns must be interpreted in a cautious
manner. Injuries resulting from police use of firearms are most often
intended, as officers are trained to shoot center mass. Injuries and damages
resulting from police pursuit driving are most often accidental, as a
vehicle should be used as a weapon in only the most extreme case. As more
information about police pursuit driving is gathered and analyzed, results
from research on the use of firearms must be incorporated, but recommendations
for one must not be attached blindly to the other.
Alpert, Geoffrey P., et al. Police Pursuits: What We Know. Washington,
DC: Police Executive Research Forum, 2000. Call Number: HV8080.P9 P65
2000
Abstract: Police Pursuits: What We Know goes beyond previous pursuit research
by compiling extensive data from four diverse sites and a national survey,
and examining the issue not only from the police perspective, but from
the perspectives of the public and offenders as well. The book also summarizes
and builds on some key prior research, examines liability and risk-management
issues, and makes specific policy recommendations for police agencies.
American Justice. Hot Pursuit. New York: A&E Home Video, 1996. Call
Number: HV8080.P9 H68 1996 AV Notes: VHS, (50 minutes), color.
Abstract: Go behind the scenes with American Justice as we examine real-life
pursuits conducted by land, air and sea.
Anonymous. "High-Speed Vehicle Pursuit: A Decision Making Matrix."
Crime & Justice International (May/June 2004): pp. 30+.
Abstract: The determination of liability with respect to high-speed pursuits
has become an analytical puzzle due to what may appear to be inconsistent
decisions by various courts. When federal court decisions are broken down,
they can provide officers with a level of guidance for conduct during
pursuits.
Anonymous. "Wrongful Death--Car Chase Leaves Innocent Bystander Dead."
Police Department Disciplinary Bulletin (January 2003): pp. 6-7. Notes:
Available full text on Proquest (CJPI)
Abstract: In "Nguyen v. City of Westminster," the Court of Appeals
of California affirmed a lower court ruling that the city was immune from
liability for the death of a bystander injured in a police pursuit of
a stolen vehicle.
Bellah, John. "Cutting Out the Chase." Police (April 2003):
pp. 28-31.
Abstract: Tragic accidents involving innocent motorists have forced some
law enforcement agencies to modify their pursuit policies.
________. " How to Conduct a High-Speed Pursuit." Police (April
2003): pp. 22+.
Abstract: Because you never know what will happen, always be prepared
for a pursuit. Keep your vehicle and yourself in working order, know your
department's pursuit policies, and be ready for whatever comes your way.
Blades, Steven D. "In Hot Pursuit." Police (July 2002): pp.
66-7.
Abstract: There are numerous concerns that an officer must consider before
putting the pedal to the metal. While police pursuits are a necessary
part of police work and should not be banned, officers should be aware
of the potential danger and terminate pursuits when the risk of injury
outweighs the benefit of catching the suspect.
Bombardier Productions. Police in Pursuit. West Long Beach, NJ: White
Star, 1990. Call Number: HV8080.P9 P65 1990 AV Notes: VHS, (43 minutes):
color.
Abstract: A series of video recordings made by British police in "hot
pursuit" of traffic offenses.
Bondurant, Bob and Edwin Snow. Bob Bondurant on Police and Pursuit Driving.
Osceola, WI: MBI, 2000. Call Number: HV8080.P9 B65 2000
Abstract: This comprehensive volume follows the curriculum of the Bondurant
School's respected law enforcement driving course. It is an ideal reference
for public safety personnel and it also provides behind-the-scenes insights
for driving enthusiasts.
Chemerinsky, Erwin. "High-Speed Chases." Trial (February 2001):
pp. 26-27.
Abstract: Under what circumstances can the government or government officers
be held liable for injuries that result from high-speed police chases?
In County of Sacramento v. Lewis, the U.S. Supreme Court made recovery
by injured plaintiffs extremely difficult. The Court held that due process
is violated only if the officers' behavior "shocks the conscience,"
which requires demonstrating that the officers acted with intent of causing
harm to the victim.
Connor, Greg. "Re-Examining Pursuit Related Roadblocks." Law
& Order (May 2002): pp. 22-3.
Abstract: For years, roadblocks have been utilized as a last resort by
many agencies when a pursued suspect continues to place innocent drivers
and pedestrians at risk of serious bodily harm or death. By re-examining
the essential elements of roadblock design and deployment, officers and
agencies may recognize the value and viability of one of law enforcement's
most traditional and tested tactics.
________. "Wrong Paradigm?: Pursuit Terms and Tactics." Law
& Order (July 2003): pp. 64, 66.
Abstract: If law enforcement is going to continue to engage in the practice
of police pursuits, it must integrate a goal of control into its paradigm
of performance. Such a position would require an agency to continue its
focus on the foundations of its function, including those fundamental
facets of a pursuit. In this manner, professional law enforcement can
more adequately address the idiosyncrasies of this critical enforcement
task, and pro-actively design and deliver an integrated and trained response.
Crandell, Doug. "High Speed High Stakes." Atlanta (November
2005): pp. 76, 78. Notes: Available full text on Wilsonweb
Abstract: One person dies every day as a result of police pursuits, the
majority of which begin after routine traffic violations.
Daniels, Wayne and Lynette Spratley. "Brainpower Not Horsepower:
Teaching Officers How to End Pursuits." Law & Order (July 2003):
pp. 85-89.
Abstract: Teaching officers to know when and how to pursue a fleeing vehicle
is not enough. Officers have to be taught when and how to end a pursuit.
The parameters of pursuit are set by departmental policy and every officer
with keys to a patrol car must know how to apply that policy properly.
Daniels, Wayne H. "Training for Pursuit Driving." Law &
Order (November 2000): pp. 80-3.
Abstract: Police pursuit driving classes should have two distinct parts,
a classroom session and a hands-on driving component on a course designed
by an instructor. Liability issues that pertain to pursuit driving must
be thoroughly explained.
Hicks, Wendy L. "Police Vehicular Pursuits: An Overview of Research
and Legal Conceptualizations for Police Administrators." Criminal
Justice Policy Review (March 2003): pp. 75-95.
Abstract: Research into the realm of police pursuits is fraught with many
complex, often conflicting methodologies, findings and legal decisions.
This article attempts to make sense of some of the scholarly attempts
that have been made to date. Many studies have presented pursuits as posing
serious safety risks to the general public, whereas other research has
found pursuits to be relatively safe. Ultimately, it remains the responsibility
of policy makers and administrators to devise and implement effective,
efficient guidelines with regard to vehicular pursuits. Only through improving
written policy will negative outcomes such as accidents, injuries, fatalities
and litigation wane. New tactics and devices with proven technological
potential are described.
Hill, John. "High-Speed Police Pursuits: Dangers, Dynamics, and Risk
Reduction." FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin (July 2002): pp. 14-18.
Abstract: High-speed police pursuits and the inherent risk of injury and
death that can result constitute an important law enforcement and police
safety issue. Research indicates that too many restraints placed on the
police regarding pursuits can put the public at risk. On the other hand,
insufficient controls on police pursuits can result in needless accidents
and injuries.
Lesh, David. "Reducing Civil Liability Related to High-Speed Pursuits."
Sheriff (March/April 2003): pp. 29-30.
Abstract: One of the biggest challenges facing law enforcement in the
coming years is the need to reduce civil liability from collisions related
to high-speed pursuits. This article offers a number of practical, low-cost
suggestions to reduce civil liability stemming from these, sometimes tragic
events.
Loberg, Gary. "Pursuit Driving: What Sheriffs Need to Know."
Sheriff (March/April 2003): pp. 28-9.
Abstract: It behooves sheriffs and law enforcement executives to be familiar
with the case law by which their agencies will be judged. The law enforcement
leader must consider many factors when writing a pursuit policy. Among
these are moral and ethical considerations.
Martin, Jeff. "Pursuit Termination: A Lifesaver?" Law &
Order (July 2001): pp. 30-33.
Abstract: Because the belief that fleeing suspects will begin driving
safely when pursuing police units terminate pursuits, plaintiffs and certain
interest groups hold law enforcement professionals responsible for the
resulting tragedies. Due to the tendency by detractors and plaintiffs
to put law enforcement professionals in a position of such culpability,
as well as the limited research on this topic, a survey of police helicopter
(air-support) crews from across the country was performed to obtain information
about suspect driving behavior after ground units have terminated pursuits.
O'Connor, Patrick T. and Jr. William L. Norse. "Police Pursuits:
A Comprehensive Look at the Broad Spectrum of Police Pursuit Liability
and Law." Mercer Law Review (Winter 2006): pp. 11-48. Notes: Available
full text on Westlaw
Abstract: This article focuses on the legal liability associated with
law enforcement officers and municipalities for injuries arising out of
high-speed pursuits and emergency responses. It also discusses other forces
and trends involved in the realm of police pursuit law.
Owens, Michael Douglas. "The Inherent Constitutionality of the Police
Use of Deadly Force to Stop Dangerous Pursuits." Mercer Law Review
: pp. 1599-643. Notes: Available full text on Westlaw
Abstract: It is the position of this paper that whenever someone uses
a vehicle to flee unlawfully from the police, the police are justified
in using deadly force to end the pursuit if the suspect drives in any
manner inconsistent with the safe operation of a vehicle. Not only is
deadly force constitutional in these circumstances, it is warranted both
from a tactical and "interests of society" perspective. In short,
the risks of injury or death from police pursuits should be upon the violators
who, by their flight, create the risks, rather than upon the citizenry
in general. This article will illustrate the inherent constitutionality
of using deadly force.
Peterson, Craig. "Why Cops Can't Drive." [http://www.policeone.com/pc_print.asp?vid=129741].
Abstract: "It costs too much." That’s the usual answer
to the seldom-asked question: Why don't we spend more on training to mold
our officers into superior drivers? At first glance the objection to this
cost appears valid. Departments don't have a spare $10 million to construct
a driver-training facility, and many commanders blanch at the thought
of taking an experienced officer out of service for a week and laying
out big bucks for advanced driver training. But, while most departments
ignore the toll in mangled police vehicles and officers injured or killed,
not to mention the collateral damage inflicted on the public, simply accepting
it as the unavoidable byproduct of police work, two departments, Fairfax
County and San Bernardino County, have acted to change the status quo
and fix the problem.
Pipes, Chris and Dominick Pape. "Police Pursuits and Civil Liability."
FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin (July 2001): pp. 16-21.
Abstract: As many as 40 percent of all motor vehicle police pursuits end
in collisions and some of these result in nearly 300 deaths each year
of police officers, offenders or innocent third party individuals. Because
many police pursuits result in accidents and injuries, agencies and officers
become subjects of civil lawsuits. Initiated in state or federal courts,
these lawsuits have resulted cumulatively in case law that directs law
enforcement agencies to develop pursuit policies. The U.S. Supreme Court
recently issued a ruling that has changed the threshold of negligence
before an agency or officer can be held liable, which will impact police
agencies across the United States.
Rivara, F. P. and C.D. Mack. "Motor Vehicle Crash Deaths Related
to Police Pursuits in the United States." Injury Prevention vol.10,
no. 2(2004): pp. 93-5.
Abstract: There were 2654 fatal crashes involving 3965 vehicles and 3146
fatalities during a nine- year study period. Of these, 1088 were people
not in the fleeing vehicle. These crashes often occurred at high speed,
in the night, on local roads. Most of the pursued drivers had prior motor
vehicle-related convictions. Many deaths related to police pursuits are
to innocent victims. Given that most of the pursued drivers had prior
convictions, an alternative means of detaining them should be explored.
Sharp, Arthur. "The Dynamics of Vehicle Chases in Real Life."
Law & Order (July 2003): pp. 68+.
Abstract: There are two types of police chases: the Hollywood pursuit,
in which every police car in a three-state area is involved; and the real
pursuits, which rarely involve more than three vehicles. Police activity
that is more restricted or controversial than vehicular pursuits may not
exist. Contemporary officers cannot take lightly the decision regarding
the initiation of a vehicular pursuit. They must carefully weigh all factors
included in their departmental policies, the best interests of everyone
who might be affected by the decision, etc. Administrators must also keep
the same factors in mind as they visit and revisit their policies. Changing
vehicular pursuit policies as the situation dictates is advisable, and
it may keep Hollywood chases right where they belong: in movies and on
television screens.
Singh, Shruti Date. "City Is Tapping the Brakes on Cop Car Chases."
Crain's Chicago Business (May 31, 2004): pp. 36-7. Notes: Available full
text on Wilsonweb
Abstract: Chicago is among those cities clamping down on pursuits. The
number of chases fell 42 percent to 362 last year from 625 in 2002. But
the city continues to give its officers wide latitude in deciding whether
to put the pedal to the metal. Its year-old policy bans chases for minor
traffic offenses or thefts, but leaves other incidents to the officers'
discretion.
Vaughan, Nathan. "Overgeneralization of the Hot Pursuit Doctrine
Provides Another Blow to the Fourth Amendment in Middletown V. Flinchum."
Akron Law Review vol. 37, no. 3(2004): pp. 509-48. Notes: Available full
text on Wilsonweb
Abstract: The rule announced in Flinchum allows police to circumvent various
Fourth Amendment protections. Additionally, increases in police power
are likely to escalate the number of Section 1983 lawsuits filed against
law enforcement.
Warren, Rocky and Mitchell Olsen. "Large Vehicle Pursuits and Attacks."
Law & Order (July 2002): pp. 26-9.
Abstract: To stop a large vehicle pursuit, where reasonable cause exists,
the use of lethal force methods in a way that will most likely result
in less-lethal conclusion will be advocated. To accomplish this it is
going to take coordination and cooperation of the highest order, both
between agencies and individual officers.
Witczak, Tom. "Proactive Pursuit Policies." Law & Order
(July 2003): pp. 131-33.
Abstract: All too often, officers get into a pursuit, the adrenaline starts
pumping, and they lose track of the purpose of the pursuit, as well as
their safety and the safety of the general public. Witczak discusses the
different policies on police pursuit operations. He holds that none of
the varied positions can stand on their own, and that guidance should
be provided for the officers who are out on patrol and need to make a
decision on the spot without delay. Not only in a pursuit situation, but
also during an emergency response.
Yates, Travis. "Law Enforcement Pursuits: Managing the Risks."
WomenPolice (Winter 2004): pp. 10-1.
Abstract: A law enforcement pursuit is one of the most dangerous tasks
a police officer performs. Here, Yates stresses four issues that perpetuate
the dangers of pursuits within law enforcement agencies.
Yates, Travis. "Police Driving.com." [http://policedriving.com].
Abstract: The site is dedicated to law enforcement driver training with
an emphasis on assisting officers and the public with a safer environment
as it pertains to police pursuits. |
|